Bitter Resistance: Clarendon County, South Carolina

page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4

On May 28, 1951, Thurgood Marshall, Robert Carter, and Spottswood Robinson brought the case before a three-judge panel at the federal courthouse in Charleston, South Carolina. The defendant was Roderick W. Elliott, a local sawmill owner and the school board chairman.

The lawyers argued that segregated schools harmed black children psychologically and violated the Fourteenth Amendment’s guarantee of equal protection under the law. Two of the judges, citing the Plessy v. Ferguson decision of 1896, held that separate-but-equal facilities were constitutional and ruled against the parents.

Judge Waring
J. Waties Waring, a member of the three-judge panel, wrote the dissenting opinion. He was one of many white southerners who stood up for justice at a time when many of his neighbors clung to old ways. As a supporter of equal rights, he endured both psychological and physical intimidation and eventually moved from Charleston to New York City.
(Courtesy of Moorland-Springarn Research Center)

| I am of the opinion that all of the legal guideposts, expert testimony, common sense and reason point unerringly to the conclusion that the system of segregation in education adopted and practiced in the state of South Carolina must go and go now. Segregation is per se inequality.
—Judge J. Waties Waring, in dissent, Briggs v. Elliott

| The Negro child is made to go to an inferior school; he is branded in his own mind as inferior...You can teach such a child the Constitution, anthropology and citizenship, but he knows it isn’t true.
—Thurgood Marshall, concluding remarks, Briggs v. Elliott

Brief submitted to the Supreme Court
The NAACP lawyers appealed the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court for the October term in 1952. (Courtesy of Supreme Court of the United States)

Back to top

Continue to Topeka, Kansas